Partial Trapeziotrapezoid Resection and Thumb Range of Movement After Trapeziometacarpal Joint Fusion—A Biomechanical Study

Abstract

Purpose: Trapeziometacarpal (TMC) joint arthrodesis is an effective treatment for stage III osteoarthritis. Although this procedure alleviates thumb pain and restores grip power and pinch strength, persistent limitation of thumb movement is inevitable. This biomechanical study aimed to investigate the altered kinematics of thumb circumduction motion after TMC joint arthrodesis and subsequent excision of the trapeziotrapezoid (TT) and trapezio-second metacarpal (T-2MC) joint spaces. Methods: Eight cadaver upper extremities were mounted on a custom testing apparatus. The hand and carpal bones were fixed to the apparatus, except for the first metacarpal bone, trapezium, and trapezoid. A 50-g load was applied at the tip of the first metacarpal head to generate passive thumb circumduction. An electromagnetic tracking system measured the angular and rotational displacement of the first metacarpal. All specimens were tested in 4 conditions: intact, after simulated TMC joint fusion, after subsequent excision of 3 mm of bone at the TT joint space, and after additional 3 mm resection at the T-2MC joint space. Results: After simulated TMC arthrodesis, the range of angular motion of thumb circumduction decreased to 25% that of the intact thumb. Subsequent resections at the TT and T-2MC joint spaces increased circumduction ranges to 49% (TT joint) and 73% (TT plus T-2MC joints) that of the intact thumb. The range of thumb rotational motion showed a similar trend. Conclusions: Trapeziometacarpal arthrodesis decreased the range of both angular and rotational motion during thumb circumduction. Subsequent resections at the paratrapezial space increased the range of thumb motion, suggesting that hypermobility of the paratrapezial joints increases thumb mobility after TMC joint fusion. Clinical relevance: Patients with hypermobile paratrapezial joints may have larger thumb movement after TMC joint fusion. Additional resections of the TT and T-2MC joint spaces may further mobilize the thumb in patients who complain of stiffness after TMC fusion.